Sausage Links

 

Thanksgiving

Lots of interesting links before Thanksgiving:

The Ferguson Lie — the Grand Jury was Kabuki Theatre at its worst:

That the grand jury did not indict Ferguson Police Officer Darren Wilson was a foregone conclusion.  To those of us who don’t have to look up a study or read a law review article to understand how indictments happen in the real world, the outcome was clear when St. Louis County District Attorney Bob McCulloch announced that he would present all the evidence to the grand jury.  Wachtler’s “ham sandwich” has grown trite in this discussion.

The Ferguson Lie is an appeal to our sense of fairness and transparency.  We were played.  McCulloch’s lengthy spiel before announcing “no true bill” was to spread the lie.  To the ear of the media, McCulloch’s pitch was appealing; the grand jury heard all the evidence.  The grand jury transcript will be disclosed to provide complete transparency.  Witnesses lied to the media, but the grand jury heard the truth. The grand jury saw the hard evidence. Nine whites and three blacks, so no one would think that the grand jury was denied the voice of people of color, sat on the grand jury, which met for 25 sessions and more than 70 hours of testimony.

The grand jury did the dirty work that America needed done.  The grand jury has spoken.

This is the lie.

The description of what happened with the grand jury, how it heard all the evidence, how it will be transparent, is intended to appease our innate sense of fairness. Americans love things that appear fair, even if we don’t quite understand what actual fairness means. This sounds as if it was done as well, as fairly, as it could possibly be done.  But it’s a lie.

“All the evidence” is a phrase that applies to a trial.  A trial is a procedure that happens in an open courtroom, where adversaries zealously present their case and challenge the other side’s case.  It is transparent because we can watch it unfold, develop, happen before our eyes. We hear the questions and answers, the objections and rulings. We hear the request to admit evidence and the voir dire and challenge to its admission.  We hear the opening arguments and summations.

McCulloch put on a play in Ferguson.  His press conference announcing the foregone conclusion was remarkably in many ways, not the least of which was how he sold the argument for “no true bill” rather than the position he, as prosecutor, was duty-bound to champion.  The man charged with prosecuting killers argued the case for not indicting Wilson.

McCulloch didn’t have to go to the grand jury at all. He could have prosecuted Wilson by fiat had he wanted to do so.  He did not.  He was not going to be the person who charged Wilson with any variation of homicide.  But in deciding to take the case to the grand jury, the lie was born.

Links to the Evidence Heard By the Ferguson Grand Jury

When you review the evidence in the link above, remember, this evidence was allowed to go unchallenged by other evidence.  The important evidence is the evidence that was NOT introduced because this was not an adversarial proceeding.

Student Loan Debt Explodes

Executive Order on Immigration: The  33-page legal memorandum by the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) concludef that the president’s policy is “a permissible exercise of [the Department of Homeland Security’s] discretion to enforce the immigration laws.”

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s